TSA PreCheck vs. CLEAR vs. Digital ID: Which One Is Actually Worth Your Money?
If you spend any amount of time in airports, you’ve probably noticed something.
There are really two types of travelers.
One group practically lives in airports. They’re business travelers, road warriors, airline elites, and the people who know exactly which Starbucks has the shortest line in Terminal B.
The other group flies once or twice a year. Maybe it’s a family vacation, a cruise, or a trip to visit Grandma.
Those are two very different travelers, but today’s airport security programs have something to offer both.
The question is simple:
Which ones are actually worth paying for?
After years of flying almost every week, here’s my take on TSA PreCheck, CLEAR, and the newer Digital ID programs.
TSA PreCheck: Still the Best Value
If I could only recommend one program, it would be TSA PreCheck.
Every time.
For about $80 for five years, you’re paying roughly $16 a year to make one of the worst parts of flying dramatically easier.
With TSA PreCheck you’ll usually:
- Keep your shoes on
- Leave your laptop in your bag
- Leave liquids packed away
- Move through a much faster security line
Could you occasionally arrive at an airport where the regular security line is moving just as fast?
Of course.
It happens.
But during the busiest travel periods, especially early morning departures and evening rushes, that’s rarely the case.
Even if you only fly once or twice a year, I still think it’s worth it.
When you break the cost down, you’re spending less than one airport sandwich each year to remove a huge amount of travel stress.
That’s an easy decision.
Tommy’s Take: If you’re only going to buy one airport security program, buy TSA PreCheck.
CLEAR: Convenient, But Harder to Justify
CLEAR works differently.
Instead of replacing TSA screening, it verifies your identity using facial recognition or fingerprints before you reach the TSA officer.
Then you’re escorted to the front of the ID verification line.
Today, CLEAR Plus costs about $219 per year, although many premium credit cards and airline loyalty programs include it for free or at a discount.
I’ll admit it.
Using CLEAR feels pretty cool.
You walk up to the kiosk.
It recognizes your face.
For a second, you feel like you’ve stepped into the future.
A couple of years ago, though, I noticed something frustrating.
I was getting randomly asked to show my driver’s license so often that it defeated much of the convenience.
Fortunately, that seems to have improved significantly.
When CLEAR Makes Sense
CLEAR can absolutely save time at airports like:
- Atlanta (ATL)
- Denver (DEN)
- Las Vegas (LAS)
- Seattle (SEA)
Especially during heavy business travel hours.
The problem is this:
TSA PreCheck has become so efficient that many mornings, the PreCheck line moves almost as fast as CLEAR.
Because of that, CLEAR feels less like a necessity and more like a premium convenience.
If your credit card pays for it?
Absolutely use it.
If you’re paying the full annual fee yourself?
I’d think twice.
Tommy’s Take: CLEAR is nice to have. TSA PreCheck is the one I’d actually pay for.
Digital ID: The New Kid on the Block
The newest option is airline Digital ID.
Delta, United, and several other airlines now allow eligible travelers to verify their identity using facial recognition instead of showing a driver’s license.
Here’s the best part:
It’s free.
You’ll typically need:
- TSA PreCheck
- A valid U.S. passport
- An eligible airline account
- To opt in before your trip
Once you’re enrolled, participating airports can recognize you automatically as you move through security.
The biggest advantage today?
Not many people know about it.
Because adoption is still relatively low, these dedicated lanes often move surprisingly quickly.
Will that always be true?
Probably not.
As more travelers discover Digital ID, those lines will likely become busier.
But today, it’s one of the better-kept secrets in airport security.
Which One Should You Choose?
You fly once or twice a year
✅ Get TSA PreCheck.
That’s all you need.
You fly every month
Get:
- TSA PreCheck
- Digital ID (it’s free)
- CLEAR if your credit card includes it
That combination gives you the most flexibility.
You’re deciding between TSA PreCheck and CLEAR
Choose TSA PreCheck.
Every single time.
Price Comparison
| Program | Approximate Cost | My Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| TSA PreCheck | ~$80 for 5 years | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Must Have |
| CLEAR Plus | ~$219 per year | ⭐⭐⭐ Nice if Included |
| Airline Digital ID | Free | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ Absolutely Sign Up |
Final Thoughts
Airport security has changed dramatically over the last few years.
Programs that once felt exclusive have become common, while newer technologies like Digital ID are quietly making the airport experience even easier.
My advice is simple.
Start with TSA PreCheck.
If your credit card gives you CLEAR, enjoy it.
And absolutely enroll in your airline’s Digital ID program. It costs nothing and could save you time on your next trip.
One last piece of advice.
No matter what security program you’re using, none of them can fix showing up late to the airport.
Give yourself plenty of time, relax, and start your trip the right way.
Travel smart,
Tommy Pags


